The arena of Nickelodeon All-Star Brawl is about to get a whole lot more crowded, and the fans have spoken loud and clear about who they want to see throw down next. Ever since the developers at Ludosity teased the promise of post-launch DLC characters, the game's passionate community has been buzzing with speculation and wishlists. In a democratic display of cartoon carnage cravings, players on the game's most active subreddit rallied together, casting their votes to create a definitive ranking of the most requested new combatants. The results? A fascinating mix of nostalgic icons, meme-fueled dreams, and a few pleasant surprises that could shape the future of this chaotic crossover fighter.

🥇 The Top Tier Trio: Fan-Favorite Frontrunners

Leading the charge is the boy genius himself, Jimmy Neutron. Topping the community poll, Jimmy's absence from the base roster was a head-scratcher for many. With his inventive gadgets and cerebral style, he's widely considered the most obvious and logical choice for a DLC addition. Imagine the possibilities: a Hypercube for trapping opponents, a Jet Pack recovery move, or a Robo-Dog summon for assist attacks. His inclusion seems almost scientifically inevitable.

Hot on his heels in second place is the metallic marvel, Jenny Wakeman (XJ-9) from My Life as a Teenage Robot. Unlike some characters tangled in licensing webs, Jenny comes with a developer-confirmed advantage: there are no rights issues holding her back. This makes her a prime candidate, or a 'shoo-in,' as they say. Her move-set practically writes itself, featuring rocket fists, helicopter hair, and various built-in weaponry, offering a unique blend of ranged and mecha-style combat.

Rounding out the coveted top three is Timmy Turner, the fairy-wishing star of The Fairly OddParents. Despite his massive popularity, his path to the brawl is currently blocked by a rather un-magical problem: distribution rights. The complex web of ownership surrounding the character makes his addition sadly unlikely for now, leaving fans to simply wish upon a star for a future miracle.

🎭 The Meme Machine & The Fire Prince

The community's sense of humor shines through with the next popular picks. In fourth and fifth place sit two characters who have ascended through meme culture: Squidward Tentacles and Hugh Neutron. Squidward's perpetually grumpy demeanor and potential for clarinet-based attacks have captured players' imaginations. Meanwhile, Jimmy's dad, Hugh, with his iconic dance moves and love for eating boiled potatoes, represents a deep-cut, hilarious choice that has gained surprising momentum since the game's launch.

Securing the sixth spot is a character who would bring some elemental balance to the fight: Zuko from Avatar: The Last Airbender. This request makes perfect sense, as the current roster lacks a dedicated firebender. Zuko would complete the elemental trio alongside Aang (air) and Korra (water), allowing for thrilling Avatar-State showdowns. His move-set could feature his dual dao swords, powerful fire blasts, and maybe even a final smash involving his iconic Blue Spirit persona.

🔍 Data-Mined Clues & Likely Contenders

Beyond pure popularity, some characters have hard evidence supporting their potential arrival. Rocko from Rocko's Modern Life ranks highly and seems particularly plausible. Data miners have uncovered voice lines from the game's announcer calling out his name, a strong indicator that he's already in development. As a beloved legacy character, his wallaby ways would be a welcome addition.

Furthermore, the game's files hint at a broader strategy. Voice lines have also been found referencing:

• The remaining Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles (Donatello, Raphael, Michelangelo)

• Jimmy Neutron (corroborating his top poll position)

• Squidward

• Rocko

This suggests Ludosity is actively working on expanding the roster with these fan-favorite figures.

🐾 The Long Shots & The Guaranteed Brawlers

The community's wishlist also includes some dream picks that face steeper odds. Po from Kung Fu Panda appeared on the list, but as a DreamWorks property, his crossover into the Nickelodeon universe seems like a distant, dragon-warrior-sized dream. Other notable mentions include the energetic El Tigre, the photo-snapping Snap from ChalkZone, and the logging duo The Angry Beavers.

However, two characters didn't even need to be polled to generate hype. Shredder and Garfield are all but confirmed for the next wave of DLC. Extensive data mining has revealed that both villains—the Foot Clan leader and the lasagna-loving cat—have nearly finished fighter data already embedded within the game's code. Their arrival seems not a matter of if, but when.

Rank	Character	Series	Likelihood	Key Reason
1	Jimmy Neutron	The Adventures of Jimmy Neutron	⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐	Top poll choice, data-mined voice lines
2	Jenny Wakeman	My Life as a Teenage Robot	⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐	No rights issues, high fan demand
3	Timmy Turner	The Fairly OddParents	⭐	High demand but major rights hurdles
4/5	Squidward / Hugh Neutron	SpongeBob SquarePants / Jimmy Neutron	⭐⭐⭐	Massive meme popularity
6	Zuko	Avatar: The Last Airbender	⭐⭐⭐⭐	Fills elemental role, high demand
7	Rocko	Rocko's Modern Life	⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐	Data-mined announcer line, legacy icon
N/A	Shredder / Garfield	TMNT / Garfield	⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐	Near-complete data found in game files

As 2026 unfolds, the future of Nickelodeon All-Star Brawl looks brighter—and more chaotic—than ever. The dialogue between developers and players, evidenced by these polls and data discoveries, shows a game evolving with its community. Whether it's the scientific smash of Jimmy, the robotic rage of Jenny, or the unexpected fury of a dancing Hugh Neutron, the next round of DLC is poised to deliver the nostalgic, chaotic, and hilarious brawls that fans are clamoring for. The only question left is: who will you main next? 🤔✨